Upper Crust Pizza: A Key Largo Favorite for Over 20 Years

Owners were amazing! It was our first time at Upper Crust and they were helpful with suggestions. I ordered a sub. The bread is made fresh there. The sub came out warm. Bread was soft and almost melted in my mouth. We also ordered a pizza. It was also very good. Sauce is made in house as well. When we come back to the area, we will definitely be back

There are many pizza options on the Keys. As you drive down you will see. But DO NOT MISS THIS ONE!!!! OMG this was deliciousness. Every bite I was hoping that I had a bigger stomach. Just soooo good. Their flavors were so well balanced and their treys keep the pizza hot while you enjoy it. On top of that, the owners are amazing. The wife is super nice and friendly and she will happily engage in a conversation about their European heritage. The husband is beer enthusiast. If you like international beer collection then definitely have a chat with him. He will explain to you every option offered and some of his vintage options too. We stumbled upon this treasure almost by an accident but next time we visit, we are not missing it, for sure!!!!

Wow, what a fantastic place! The food was absolutely amazing. The sauce for the garlic rolls was pure heaven and I could have drank it. The pizza dough was freshly made and had a light, crisp texture. The staff was friendly and made us feel welcomed! We will definitely be coming back.

Upper Crust Pizza is such a great community member! Plus, the food is delicious....we ordered 2 large pizzas, one veggie and one house specialty, yum yum...can't wait for the leftovers plus 2 pieces of homemade key lime pie, which was 100% homemade AND delightful. Thanks ya'll, for the delivery!

The pizza was delicious and the vibe was just what we needed. Martina and David make an excellent pizza and are amazing proprietors. If you are in Key Largo swing by for an excellent pie. Lots a great choices.

We had a great experience last night at the Upper Crust. Cpt Alex from Rainbow Reef turned us on to the best pizza in town and our mate seconded the choice without hesitation. We order the garlic bread, and it was on point with great flavor and plenty of oil. We also ordered the Chillax Pizza and it was amazing. Great combination of flavors on this pizza pineapple and peppers. We had them old the red peppers but it was still delicious.

Love Upper Crust Pizza! We’ve tried most of the ‘special’ pizzas and several ‘make your own’ and all have been delicious with fresh ingredients and plentiful toppings. The service is awesome too. Very friendly and welcoming. This is a must stop in the Key Largo, Tavernier, & Islamorada area.

This is one of Key Largo's best kept secrets. Martina and David are so intentional about their food and beer selection. All their ingredients are fresh and as natural as possible (which means you feel great after eating the best pizza in town)! We came back multiple times for pizza and the company :] And that Key Lime Pie....unreal. It just the right amount of tart with a crust that you can absolutely tell is homemade. We Will be back!! Salute!